OUR STAFF
Fr. Esau McCaulley
Senior Pastor (Rector)
Fr. Esau is the founding pastor and Rector of All Saints Naperville. He has been an ordained Anglican clergy person for over 15 years. During his ministry, he has served as a youth pastor, college pastor, associate pastor, and Rector (Head Pastor) in multiple congregations across America and abroad, including parishes in Japan and Scotland.
He received his Undergraduate degree in history from the University of the South. He received his Master of Divinity from Gordon Conwell Theological Seminary, a master of Sacred Theology from Nashotah House Theological Seminary, and a PhD in New Testament from the University of St. Andrews, where he studied under the direction of N.T. Wright. In addition to his ministry as an Anglican clergy person, he is also an associate professor of New Testament at Wheaton College.
He is married to Mandy, a pediatrician and captain in the U.S. Navy reserves. Together they have four wonderful children.
In his free time, he loves reading fantasy literature and spending time with his family. He is an avid sports fan, usually basketball and football, but he has recently become obsessed with Premier League soccer!
Rev. Heather Mathews
D. Min Associate Pastor for Congregational Life
Mtr. Heather is our Associate Pastor. She provides strategic leadership to our church operations, staff, and ministries. Heather also preaches, teaches, provides pastoral care, and assists in the liturgy.
Heather is also the Doctor of Ministry Program Manager at Wheaton College Graduate School. Heather has worked as a pastor, church planter, non-profit leader, and global worker for over twenty years. She was previously ordained a non-denominational context, but is now ordained as a deacon in the ACNA through our diocese, Churches for the Sake of Others. She has a D.Min. from Fuller Seminary, an M.A. in Educational Ministry and an M.A. in Counseling Ministry from Trinity Evangelical Divinity School, and a B.S. in Biomedical Engineering from Northwestern University in Evanston, IL.
Sarah Kwan 关琦慧 -
Worship Pastor
Sarah has 10 years of experience in leading worship. She was born in California and grew up in China as a missionary kid (MK)/third-culture kid (TCK). Music and performance have always been a significant part of her life, and worshipping through song feels like a calling to her. She is passionate about creating spaces where people can come together and share a deep connection in the Lord.
Sarah’s vision for her worship ministry is to lead God’s people in Christ-centered, Gospel-centered, and Bible-centered worship, where they are encouraged and empowered to encounter the cross, communally and individually, all for the purpose of God’s glory and the unification of the church. Sarah's worship ministry aims to create a worship space that glorifies God through the arts, including music, dance, drama, and visual art. This space will emphasize theologically rich worship music, the act of calling on the name of Jesus, and the acknowledgment of God’s presence made known through the Holy Spirit in the gathering of His people, all to model worship practices that point to God.
Sarah deeply enjoys listening to people's stories and being part of developing their true, authentic selves. Sarah aspires to become a full-time performer as a worship leader, musical theater performer, or full-time singer. She is strong in leadership, organization, problem-solving, and adaptability. Some of her hobbies include going to plays, musicals, and live music events, exploring new places, writing, reading, having deep conversations with people, and cooking.
Lindsey Goetz
Pastor for Children’s Formation
Lindsey has served for 10 years in children's ministry and also works as the Resource Director at the Center for Faith and Children at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School, where she co-hosts the podcast "The Child in Our Midst," which explores the unique perspective of children in their faith journeys. She is also trained as a spiritual director for children, and she loves to help kids engage with God in playful, childlike ways.
Lindsey has a Bachelor of Arts in Elementary Education from Trinity International University, and is currently pursuing an MA in educational ministries at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School.
Lindsey enjoys combining her knowledge of practical ministry and children's spirituality to engage children as full participants in the church in innovative ways. As a mom of five, Lindsey understands the joys and challenges of raising children and loves to help parents & kids notice the ways God is already at work in their family's life. She looks forward to bringing her deep value for children and her knowledge of faith formation to the All Saints community.
In her free time, Lindsey enjoys watercolor painting, writing, and roller skating. She also loves going to concerts and convincing her kids to take nature hikes with her.
Jeremiah McNicholas
Sound & Production Director
Jeremiah has over ten years of ministry experience, both as a staff member and a volunteer. He developed a passion for serving the local church while interning with his hometown church in North Vernon, Indiana.
Feeling called to ministry, Jeremiah moved to Louisville, Kentucky, in 2020 to study Music and Worship Studies at Boyce College. During this time, he worked as an Audio-Visual Technician for the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary, where he refined his skills in stage management and audio-visual production.
Jeremiah also faithfully served as the worship intern at his church in Louisville, Vine Street Baptist, leading them in Christ-centered worship in order to give glory to God.
While in Louisville, he met his wife, Rachel, and they moved to the Chicagoland area in June 2025.
In his free time, Jeremiah enjoys backpacking, camping, gaming, and cooking. He and his wife love watching the Food Network and have a long list of restaurants they hope to visit one day!